Most Overated Steam Locomotives in the World

1 min read

Deviation Actions

Engine97's avatar
By
Published:
1.1K Views
Union Pacific 4-8-8-4

Reasoning: Commonly mislabeled as the heaviest, strongest and longest steam locomotive ever built. The UP Challengers were much more handsome.


Southern Pacific 4-8-4 GS-4 (4449)

Reasoning: They had ugly faces. The colors were nice, but the Southern Pacific had nicer engines with the same color scheme. Look up the GS-6.


Nickel Plate Road (765)

Reasoning: 765 gets way too much love, and her sisters not enough. Sure, it's nice to have an engine as large and as pretty as 765 running (I myself am a huge fan of 765) but other NKP engines like the 4-6-4 170 are unknown to exist to some people. Some of these Berks need a lot of lovin, like 755 in Conneaut, Ohio, or a C&O 2-8-4 in Dennison, Ohio. How many companies have you seen make a NKP 2-8-4 apposed to a more significant model, like "Old Maude", the First American Mallet.



© 2017 - 2024 Engine97
Comments8
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
Rail-Brony-GXY's avatar
I completely agree with the Big Boy overrating. The Jabbleman Challengers do look neater, and I swear the Big Boys are the reason none of the Fetter Challengers survive!

I'd rather take a GS-5. I mean, roller bearings on all axles?! They were like the SP's on N&W J class!

I'm...rather indifferent to the Nickel Plate Berks as a whole. Granted, the Berkshire concept baffles me a little.